Inverness Shopping Park sexual assault on girl (12) court case goes on
Sentence has again been deferred on a mentally ill man who sexually assaulted a 12-year-old girl in the toilet of an Inverness store.
Philip Mackenzie is currently receiving treatment for his issues on an interim basis but his solicitor advocate Shahid Latif had previously told Inverness Sheriff Court that two recommendations from suitably qualified skilled practitioners would be required for a Compulsion Order.
In Scotland, a Compulsion Order is a court order that allows for compulsory measures, either in a hospital or community setting, for a person with a mental disorder who has been convicted of a criminal offense.
The order is initially for six months and can be extended, varied, or revoked by the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland. If the court deems the individual poses a risk of serious harm, a Restriction Order can also be added, resulting in indefinite detention.
An assessment and recommendation had already been done by one psychiatrist, but the second, although making a similar recommendation, had failed to indicate how Mackenzie met the statutory test for such an order.
Sheriff Gordon Lamont agreed and deferred sentence until July for the concerns to be resolved.
At an earlier hearing, Inverness Sheriff Court was told that it was not 35-year-old Mackenzie's fault for pulling the girl into the disabled toilet inside The Range at Inverness Shopping Park on February 2 last year, pushing her to the floor, attempting to remove the girl’s clothing and repeatedly touching her on the body.
Mackenzie had admitted the sex offence and sentence was initially deferred for a psychiatric report.
When he again appeared by video link from a mental care facility in Perth, Mr Latif explained to Sheriff Ian Cruickshank: "In order to understand him, we need to go beyond the Crown's narrative about the offence.
"He has two developmental disorders and while it is not possible to say whether there was causation between his disorders and his behaviour, there could be a correlation. He lacks insights into where the boundaries go, and there is an ability to empathise but it is not his fault.
"There were strict rules about what he could and could not do. He had with him an assistant and that person should have accompanied him to the toilet but chose not to do so.
"My client now has some understanding that the complainer was caused upset but he requires more intervention."
Sheriff Cruickshank said that he was considering a compulsion order to replace the treatment order Mackenzie was currently on. But for that to happen a second report from a psychiatrist was required.
Top stories
-
Police hunt ‘aggressive’ young thugs who wrecked dentist’s disabled chair and stole 120 year-old antique key
-
Poisonous chemicals warning for Inverness community after ‘unusual discolouration’ of burn
-
80 homes plan thrown out by Scottish Government
-
Inverness woman reaches 1000-mile mark of Land’s End to John O’Groats challenge in memory of her mum
Inverness Sheriff Court had been told that Mackenzie required 24/7 care and had been out for lunch with his carer when he asked to go to the toilet.
Because the carer could see the toilets from where he was he allowed Mackenzie to go on his own, though he should have been accompanied.
The girl had been out with her mum when she decided to go to the toilet too.
It was while she was entering the toilet corridor that Mackenzie grabbed her and pulled her into the disabled toilet.
Fiscal depute Susan Love said: “He allowed the girl to get up and asked if she wanted her phone. She walked out of the toilets and approached an elderly couple and told them what happened.
“The social worker for Mackenzie saw the complainer come out upset.
“The complainer and her mother then reported the incident to staff at the store, who then contacted police.
“The complainer was examined and had fresh bruising to her chest and abrasions to her upper left and right thighs.” Ms Love added.